Baker's Choice Pack
- 4 or 12 cookies
- Our bakers pick the flavors
- Stuffed center
Orders $55 and up ship free
Made fresh daily
Ships within 2 business days
Best within 2 weeks
Over 4 million cookies sold Over 300,000 happy customers
What people say
5 out of 5 stars
I accidentally ate the whole thing.. all three..
5 out of 5 stars
You guys did great. Not one of these cookies disappointed. They were all so rich and soft and decadent...
5 out of 5 stars
An all around great experience. Arrived quickly and in time for a Birthday celebration. We tried all the different flavors and did not find one we didn't like...
Feelin' lucky? Let the baker choose.
What is inside
- 4 or 12 cookies
- Our bakers pick the flavors
- Stuffed center
More detail
Choose a randomized 4 or 12 cookie mystery pack. We do our best to give you a variety, but you may receive multiples of the same cookie. No substitutions or special requests.
A surprise from the baker
Check individual cookie labels for ingredients and allergens.
How it ships and stays fresh
- 1Made fresh dailyreal butter, big stuffed centers
- 2Wrapped and shippedships within 2 business days
- 3At your doormost orders in about a week
- Orders $55 and up ship free
- Need it sooner? 2-day shipping at checkout
- Individually wrappedright after baking
- Freezer friendlyreheat anytime
- If anything happens to your cookies,contact us for a replacement or credit.
- Gift-safe packing slipno prices shown
Shipping and storage details
Made fresh daily. Ships within 2 business days.
Most orders arrive within about a week. Want it sooner? Choose 2-day shipping at checkout.
Orders $55 and up ship free.
Individually packaged.
Best within 2 weeks of delivery. You can also freeze them in the wrapper, then thaw and warm.
To warm: remove the wrapper. Thaw before warming. Microwave for 10 to 20 seconds.
Give them something worth unwrapping.
Send a Baker's Choice Pack to your favorite cookie person.
A few good questions
How many cookies are in the pack?
Choose a randomized 4 or 12 cookie mystery pack. We do our best to give you a variety, but you may receive multiples of the same cookie. No substitutions or special requests.
5 out of 5 stars
OMG I made the mistake of finally tasting the cookies. They are big and full of yummy goodness in every bite. My husband and I split the cookies in half for after dinner dessert. They are worth every penny.
Is shipping free?
Orders $55 and up ship free.
5 out of 5 stars
I’m amazed at how fast and fresh these cookies were delivered...
When does my order ship?
Cookies are made fresh daily and ship within 2 business days. Transit time depends on the shipping option.
5 out of 5 stars
I ordered these cookies for a birthday gift for my son. They arrived right on his birthday so shipping was perfect and came right when expected. Cookies were absolutely delicious...
How should I store the cookies?
They are best within 2 weeks of delivery, kept in their wrapper at room temperature. You can also freeze them in the same wrapper, then thaw and warm one whenever you want.
5 out of 5 stars
These cookies are delicious! Loved how they're each wrapped and they last so long.
How do I warm a cookie?
Reheating instructions are on the back of the package. Oven at 375F for 4 to 6 minutes, air fryer at 350F for 3 to 6 minutes, or microwave 10 to 20 seconds.
5 out of 5 stars
Delicious, warm for 5 seconds, mmmm, mmmmm! Arrived in 2 days! Worth every penny, huge cookies!!
Will they be fresh when they arrive?
We make cookies fresh daily and individually package each one right after it is baked, so it stays soft until you open it.
5 out of 5 stars
The cookies are always so soft and delicious. And warming them up in the microwave gives them a freshly made quality.
What if something happens to my cookies?
Each cookie is individually wrapped and packed in a sturdy box. If anything happens to your cookies, contact us for a replacement or credit. Email help@fatandweirdcookie.com.
5 out of 5 stars
Great service! Packaged really well for shipping, so the cookies arrived in perfect shape! These cookies are super special...
Do I need to bake them?
No. They arrive ready to eat. Reheating instructions are on the back of the package. Oven at 375F for 4 to 6 minutes, air fryer at 350F for 3 to 6 minutes, or microwave 10 to 20 seconds.
5 out of 5 stars
Delicious, warm for 5 seconds, mmmm, mmmmm! Arrived in 2 days! Worth every penny, huge cookies!!
How many people does a pack serve?
A MEGA cookie cuts into 4 pieces and a Lil Weirdo cuts in half, so every pack goes a long way.
5 out of 5 stars
OMG I made the mistake of finally tasting the cookies. They are big and full of yummy goodness in every bite. My husband and I split the cookies in half for after dinner dessert. They are worth every penny.
Can I ship it to someone else?
Yes. Turn on This is a gift, add your note, then enter their address as the shipping address at checkout. Packing slips never show prices.
5 out of 5 stars
I got these for my friend as a gift and as soon as she tried one she texted me asking where I found these cookies. Each one she ate she was blown away...
As seen on TV and in the press
Forbes · ABC · NBC · CBS · FOX
Kelly Osbourne and Nick Cannon ate our cookies on FOX's Beat Shazam.
“It's so good.”
Kelly Osbourne, FOX's Beat Shazam
Baker's Choice Pack Arrives by **This is a delivery estimate. Be sure to choose 2-day shipping in order for your order to arrive by this timeline.
Keep the party going
