9x All Time Fan Favorites | 5.5oz Stuffed Cookies

Favorites Pack *NEW*

$52.20 $49.50 Save 5% Sold out

Pickup currently unavailable at Fat and Weird Cookie

✨🤩 One pack to rule them all... this Favorites Pack is just that! We've assembled our all-time customer favorites to bring you the ultimate stuffed cookie experience.

Each stuffed cookie is a whopping 5.5oz and made to perfection.

Here's what you get:

  • Black Beauty 🍫 (Chocolate Cocoa)
  • Big Booty Dough 🎂 (Birthday Cake)
  • Big Sexy 🍪 (Chocolate Chip Caramel)
  • Cookies Anonymous 💙 (Blue Monster)
  • The Party Animal® 🍬 (Almond Confetti Sugar)
  • Pitchin' Tents 🔥 (S'Mores)
  • The Pudge 🥜 (Peanut Butter)
  • Massive Eruption 🌋 (Chocolate Lava Cake)
  • Lettie Doughkie 🍩 (Biscoff® & Glazed Donut)

Cookies are individually sealed for freshness. See individual cookies for nutritional information. Allergens: Contains Wheat, milk, eggs, peanuts, tree nuts, soy


You can either consume immediately upon receiving your cookie package, warm them up in the microwave if you're into that sort of thing or freeze for a later date.
From room temperature: We recommend placing them in the oven/air fryer at 350 for 4-5 minutes, but if you are in a rush, the microwave for 12-15 seconds is a good alternative. If reheating more than one cookie in the microwave, we recommend doing them individually. From frozen, we always recommend letting your cookie thaw before reheating for best results.
Our cookies (unlike other companies) are individually wrapped and heat-sealed.Most will last well over 6 weeks; however, we think it is best to freeze them if they will not be consumed the week you receive them. Frozen they will last well over 12 months!
Yes! We have found that the cookies are still tasty after freezing them for up to 12 months!
Yes, we have cookies that contain peanuts as well as other tree nuts. We also have cookies that are nut-free, but all of our cookies are processed in the same facility so there is always a chance of cross-contamination.