Cookies Anonymous
- DoughBlue cookie
- Mix-insChocolate chip cookies, cookie butter cookies, chocolate sandwich cookies and cookie dough bites
- CoreCookie butter frosting
- Orders $55 and up ship free
- Ships within 2 business days
Gourmet Stuffed Cookies
Find your flavor.
Get to know the filling: fudge, salted caramel, marshmallow, cookie butter. Your box is where the fun starts.
Chip N Drip
- DoughBrown sugar chocolate chip cookie
- Mix-insMini chocolate chips, caramel bites and sea salt
- CoreSalted caramel
Massive Eruption
- DoughDark chocolate cookie
- Mix-insMini chocolate chips and milk chocolate chunks
- CoreGooey fudge
- ToppingPowdered sugar
Caked Up
- DoughFunfetti cake batter cookie
- Mix-insWhite chocolate chips, cupcake bites and rainbow sprinkles
- CoreCake pop
Some Mores
- DoughHoney graham cookie
- Mix-insChocolate chips
- CoreMarshmallow fluff
Black Beauty
- DoughBlack cocoa cookie
- Mix-insWhite chocolate chips and chocolate sandwich cookie chunks
- CoreCookies and cream frosting
The Party Animal
- DoughAlmond confetti sugar cookie
- Mix-insFrosted animal cookies and confetti sprinkles
- CoreBlue buttercream frosting
Lettie Doughkie
- DoughCookie butter and glazed donut cookie
- Mix-insCookie butter cookies, glazed doughnut pieces and toffee bits
- CoreCookie butter
- ToppingToffee bits
Straight from a customer
Some reviews were left by customers who received a free item or discount.
5 out of 5 stars
Oh my god. This was so insanely good. I cut it in half and heat it up. That was a mistake, I might as well have just heat up the whole thing because I immediately went back to finish it. I can’t believe I waited so long to finally get some of these cookies but WOW they did not disappoint!!
Aubrie Doughkie
- DoughSugar doughnut cookie
- Mix-insWhite chocolate chips with purple and blue sprinkles
- CorePink sprinkle doughnut
The Pudge
- DoughPeanut butter cookie
- Mix-insChocolate peanut butter candies
- CoreChocolate peanut butter
Cookie Terrestrial
- DoughBrownie cookie
- Mix-insMini chocolate chips, milk chocolate chunks and brownie bites
- CoreGooey fudge
- ToppingCrunchy candy meteors
Wizard's Brew
- DoughButterscotch brown sugar cookie
- Mix-insWhite chocolate chips and butterscotch chips
- CoreButterscotch creme
- ToppingToffee chunks
Yabba Dabba
- DoughFruity cereal cookie
- Mix-insFruity cereal and cereal marshmallows
- CoreCreamy fruity frosting
Fat & Weird stuffed cookies are big, baked cookies with a filled core, made fresh daily with real butter. Buy finished cookies for delivery: choose a cookie pack or build your own box. Pick the flavors that make you smile, for your favorite humans or a little treat of your own. Every cookie is individually wrapped. Big cookie energy. A little surprise in the middle. Free shipping on orders $55 and up.
4.7 stars from 12,600+ reviews across Shop app and Yotpo.
Some reviews were left by customers who received a free item or discount.
Gourmet stuffed cookies: what's inside?
Dough. Mix-ins. The big reveal in the middle.
Cookies Anonymous is a blue cookie with chocolate chip cookies, cookie butter cookies, chocolate sandwich cookies and cookie dough bites, stuffed with a cookie butter frosting core. Some Mores is a honey graham cookie with chocolate chips and chocolate chunks, stuffed with a marshmallow core. Choose your favorite cookie flavors for your box.
What are gourmet stuffed cookies?
Our gourmet stuffed cookies are baked cookies with a filling inside. Fat & Weird fillings include cookie butter frosting, marshmallow and cake pop cores, and you can buy our finished cookies in packs or a build-your-own box.
How big are Fat & Weird stuffed cookies?
Fat & Weird MEGA stuffed cookies weigh over 5.5 oz each, and Lil Weirdos weigh over 2.5 oz each. Lil Weirdos are about half the size of a MEGA.
How do stuffed cookies ship and stay fresh?
Fat & Weird makes stuffed cookies fresh daily, wraps and heat-seals each one after baking, and ships orders within 2 business days. Most stuffed cookie orders arrive within about a week. Our cookies are best within 2 weeks of delivery.
How do I order gourmet stuffed cookies as a gift?
Order gourmet stuffed cookies as a gift by choosing a cookie pack, such as the Sampler Pack with 20 cookies for $89, or building your own box. You can add a printed message card for $3.99, and prices stay off the packing slip. Find more ideas on our cookie gifts page.
Six or twelve. All you.
Pick 6 or 12, any flavors. Made fresh daily and individually packaged. A dozen ships free.
