What is a stuffed cookie?
A stuffed cookie has a filling inside the dough, rather than only mix-ins. Here is Cookies Anonymous, cut open to show its cookie butter frosting center.
- Orders $55 and up ship free
- Ships within 2 business days
Big cookies. Bigger centers.
Best Stuffed Cookies: Go Big with Fat & Weird
Fat & Weird Cookie Co. makes MEGA stuffed cookies that are over 5.5 oz each, with a filled center in every flavor. They are made fresh daily with real butter, individually wrapped, and shipped to your door from Panama City, Florida. Over 4 million cookies sold, rated 4.7 stars from 12,600+ reviews.
Our flavors are the fun part. Yabba Dabba is a fruity cereal cookie with fruity cereal and cereal marshmallow mix-ins, stuffed with creamy fruity frosting. Caked Up is a funfetti cake batter cookie with white chocolate chips, cupcake bites and rainbow sprinkles, stuffed with a cake pop core. Some Mores is a honey graham cookie with chocolate chips and chocolate chunks, stuffed with a gooey marshmallow core. Cookie Terrestrial is a chocolate brownie cookie with crunchy galactic meteors, chocolate bits and brownie chunks, stuffed with a fudge core.
Build your own boxPacks or your own box. Orders $55 and up ship free.
A little weird.A lot stuffed.
What makes Fat & Weird different?
Filled centers. Cookies made fresh daily with real butter. Individually packaged. More than 4 million cookies sold.
MEGA or Lil Weirdos?
MEGA cookies weigh over 5.5 oz. Lil Weirdos weigh over 2.5 oz: the same stuffed cookies, just about half the size. Lil Weirdos Mini Cookies are the separate bagged bite-size product sold at Target.
What makes a stuffed cookie good?
- A real filling, not just mix-ins: frosting, fudge, caramel or cookie butter in the center.
- Size that shares: a MEGA cuts into 4, so one cookie serves 4.
- Freshness on arrival: individually wrapped right after baking; best within 2 weeks of delivery.
- Easy to warm: remove the wrapper, oven at 375F for 4 to 6 minutes, or microwave 10 to 20 seconds.
Find your flavor, build your own box
Take a peek inside each one, then choose your cookies in the box builder.
Cookies Anonymous
Our best seller: a blue cookie with chocolate chip cookie, cookie butter cookie, chocolate sandwich cookie and cookie dough bite mix-ins, stuffed with cookie butter frosting.
Explore flavor
Chip N Drip
A buttery brown sugar chocolate chip cookie with mini chocolate chips, caramel bits and a pinch of salt, stuffed with a gooey salted caramel core.
Explore flavor
Caked Up
A funfetti cake batter cookie with white chocolate chips, cupcake bites and rainbow sprinkles, stuffed with a cake pop core.
Explore flavor
Some Mores
A honey graham cookie with chocolate chips and chocolate chunks, stuffed with a gooey marshmallow core.
Explore flavorStart with a pack
A pack without the homework. Compare your box sizes below. Orders $55 and up ship free.
Favorites Pack (12/24ct)
Our all-time fan favorites in one box: Cookies Anonymous, Chip N Drip, The Pudge, Caked Up and more. Big stuffed MEGA cookies with gooey centers, made fresh daily.
- 12ct: $78.00
- 24ct: $109.00
Fat & Weird Cookie - Sampler Pack
Can't pick? Taste your way through the lineup: MEGA cookies like Cookies Anonymous and Chip N Drip, Lil Weirdos (the same stuffed cookies, about half the size) and a mystery MEGA from our bakers.
- 10ct: $59.00
- 20ct: $89.00
What press and customers say
As seen in Forbes, ABC, NBC, CBS and FOX
OMG I made the mistake of finally tasting the cookies. They are big and full of yummy goodness in every bite. My husband and I split the cookies in half for after dinner dessert. They are worth every penny.
Couldn't believe how BIG the cookies were! Not to mention delicious! It was a huge hit with my family...
Shipping, freshness and warming
Made fresh daily. Ships within 2 business days. Most orders arrive within about a week, and 2-day shipping is available at checkout. Orders $55 and up ship free.
Individually packaged. Best within 2 weeks of delivery. You can also freeze them in the wrapper, then thaw and reheat.
Remove the wrapper. For a thawed cookie: oven 375F for 4 to 6 minutes, air fryer 350F for 3 to 6 minutes, or microwave for 10 to 20 seconds.
Personalize the box
Add a printed card with your message. A box full of stuffed cookies makes a pretty sweet thank-you.
Let them choose with an E-Gift CardMeet the veteran-owned company
In April 2018, Aubrie surprised Brad with a birthday Instagram story and more than 1,000 cookies showed up. Fat & Weird Cookie Co. is veteran-owned.
Stuffed Cookies 101
What are the best stuffed cookies to order online?
Fat & Weird Cookie Co. makes MEGA stuffed cookies that are over 5.5 oz each, with a filled center in every flavor. They are made fresh daily with real butter, individually wrapped, and shipped to your door from Panama City, Florida. Over 4 million cookies sold, rated 4.7 stars from 12,600+ reviews.
What is the best cookie delivery service for stuffed cookies?
If you want stuffed cookies delivered, look for a bakery that bakes fresh, wraps each cookie, and ships nationwide. Fat & Weird ships MEGA stuffed cookies across the US, with free shipping on orders $55 and up and a paid 2-day option at checkout.
What is a stuffed cookie?
Fat & Weird Cookie Co.'s stuffed cookies have a filling inside the dough, rather than only mix-ins. Choose flavors through the box builder.
What is your best-selling stuffed cookie?
Cookies Anonymous, a blue cookie with chocolate chip, cookie butter, sandwich cookies and cookie dough bites, stuffed with cookie butter frosting.
How big are MEGA cookies and Lil Weirdos?
MEGA cookies weigh over 5.5 ounces. Lil Weirdos weigh over 2.5 ounces: the same stuffed cookies, just about half the size.
Are Lil Weirdos the same as Lil Weirdos Mini Cookies?
Lil Weirdos are stuffed cookies weighing over 2.5 ounces. Lil Weirdos Mini Cookies are the bite-size bags at Target.
Can I buy an individual stuffed cookie?
We sell packs and build-your-own boxes. Single-flavor pages guide you to the builder.
How soon do orders ship, and is shipping free?
Orders $55 and up ship free, and most arrive within about a week.
How long do stuffed cookies stay good?
They are best within 2 weeks of delivery, kept in their wrapper at room temperature. You can also freeze them in the same wrapper, then thaw and reheat. They are individually packaged.
Can I freeze stuffed cookies?
Yes. Freeze them in the wrapper. To warm, remove the wrapper and bake at 375F for 8 to 12 minutes from frozen, or 4 to 6 minutes once thawed.
How should I warm a stuffed cookie?
Remove the wrapper. For a thawed cookie, use an oven at 375F for 4 to 6 minutes, an air fryer at 350F for 3 to 6 minutes, or a microwave for 10 to 20 seconds.
