Box of Fat & Weird stuffed cookies, individually wrapped

Baker's Choice Surprise Assortment of Gourmet Stuffed Cookies by Fat & Weird Cookie

Hands breaking a Massive Eruption chocolate cookie revealing gooey fudge center

Hands pulling apart a Chip N Drip cookie to reveal a salted caramel center

Hands breaking Some Mores cookie to reveal its gooey marshmallow center

Hands breaking a Party Animal cookie revealing its blue buttercream frosting center

Mystery Cookies! Enjoy a sweet surprise with our Baker’s Choice.

Fat & Weird Cookie

Baker's Choice Pack

Name: Baker's Choice Pack
Brand: Fat & Weird Cookie
SKU: VP-BC4
Price: 28.0 USD
Availability: InStock

$28.00

4 Pack

12 Packbest valueships free

Product variants

Quantity

Pickup available at Fat and Weird Cookie

Usually ready in 2-4 days

😎 Feelin' Lucky? Get this Baker's Choice mystery 4/12 pack at a great discount!

🚨 FREE Shipping for the 12 Pack ONLY!

Baker's Choice cookies are randomized! We do our best to try and give a variety of cookies! There is a potential to get multiple of the same cookie.

No substitutions or special requests. All cookies are individually packaged for delivery.

Allergens

May contains wheat, milk, eggs, peanuts, tree nuts, soy

What Makes ’Em Fat & Weird?

Ridiculously Gooey

Especially when warmed up.

Baked Fresh

Made by hand, every day.

Loaded Up

Packed with chunks, fillings & toppings.

Big, Gourmet, Weird Cookies Made With Love

We bake our cookies by hand every day with big flavors, simple ingredients, and a whole lotta weird. Every cookie is loaded up, baked thick, and made to be enjoyed straight out of the bag or warmed up for that ridiculously gooey, melty center.

Because ordinary cookies are fine.
We make them Fat & Weird.

Made For Your Sweetest Moments

Whether you’re treating yourself, sharing with friends, or sending a little love their way, our cookies are made to make the moment better. Big, gooey, loaded with all the good stuff, and baked with a whole lotta weird.

Baked Fresh. Packed With Love.

Every cookie is baked fresh, packed with care, and ready to bring a little weirdness to your day. Big, gooey, and loaded with all the good stuff—just the way a cookie should be.