Christmas Cookie Gifts Worth Cutting Into
For Christmas cookie gifts, send Fat & Weird Cookie Company: giant stuffed cookies over 5.5 oz, made fresh daily and individually wrapped. Sending holiday gifts to clients or your team? Our corporate gifting service can send one order to many addresses from a spreadsheet.
Choose the paid 2-day shipping option ($14.99) at checkout.
Orders $55 and up ship free with standard shipping. We ship Monday to Friday, within 2 business days.
What makes these Christmas cookie gifts different
- Big. A MEGA cookie is over 5.5 oz and cuts into 4. A Lil Weirdo is over 2.5 oz and cuts in half.
- Stuffed. Every cookie has its own filled center, not just a few chips on top.
- Fresh. Made fresh daily, then individually wrapped and heat-sealed.
- Save a few. Best within 2 weeks of delivery. Set one aside before the family finds the box.
- Gift-ready. Every box includes a free printed gift note. Packing slips never show prices.
Christmas cookie gifts by who you are shopping for
Sampler Pack
10 for $59 (4 MEGA plus 6 Lil Weirdos) or 20 for $89
Ten cookies in one box: our cookie monster, chocolate chip caramel and animal cracker cookies and a baker's surprise, plus Lil Weirdo cake batter, red velvet, lava cake, s'mores, cookie butter donut and cookies and cream cookies.
Favorites Pack
12 for $78 or 24 for $109
Our 12 fan favorites in one box: our lava cake, cookie monster, chocolate chip caramel, animal cracker, s'mores, brownie, cake batter, fruity cereal, pink sprinkle donut, cookies and cream, cookie butter donut and peanut butter cup cookies.
Best Sellers Pack
4 for $34 or 8 for $68
Our four best sellers in one box: our lava cake, cookie monster, chocolate chip caramel and animal cracker cookies.
Party Pack
4 for $34 or 8 for $59
Our four party flavors in one box: our brownie, cake batter, fruity cereal and pink sprinkle donut cookies.
Lil' Weirdo Pack
9 for $35 or 18 for $58
Nine favorites at about half the size: our lava cake, cookie monster, chocolate chip caramel, animal cracker, s'mores, cake batter, cookies and cream, cookie butter donut and red velvet cookies.
Build your own box
Half dozen $49.90, dozen $79.80
Pick every flavor yourself, so the box matches the person.
Need a stocking stuffer? Add a bag of Lil Weirdos Mini Cookies ($7.99). The whole cart counts toward free shipping. Shopping at the last minute? A Fat & Weird e-gift card ($25, $50, $75 or $125) arrives by email.
How to send Christmas cookies
- Pick a pack, or build your own box.
- Enter their address at checkout and add your message for the free printed gift note, or choose the printed gift message card upgrade ($3.99).
- For Christmas gifts, follow the order-by date and shipping choice above.
They arrive ready to eat. Warm one for a few minutes and the center turns molten. Reheating instructions are on the back of the package.
Bulk holiday cookie gifts for clients and teams
Our corporate gifting service ships one order to many addresses from a spreadsheet. Concierge help building your order starts at 10 gifts; smaller orders go through the website.
- Baker's Choice 4 Pack. $37 shipped per gift.
- Sampler Pack. $59 shipped per gift.
- Baker's Choice 12 Pack. $65 shipped per gift.
For both Baker's Choice packs, we pick the flavors; flavors may repeat. Volume discounts are 5% off orders of $500 to $999 and 10% off orders of $1,000 and up.
Start on the corporate gifting page for help with your company order and fill out our address spreadsheet. Every box includes a free printed gift note. Tracking for each address is available on request.
It depends on order size, but most orders can be ready to ship within 2 business days. Allow time for delivery after that.
What people say
"I highly recommend trying Fat and Weird Cookie Company," wrote Emily Noel for Spoon University, who called our animal cracker cookie "the cookie version of the best birthday cake."
In April 2026, The Pastry Chef's Baking called them "terrific cookies" and said she would order again.
More than 4 million Fat & Weird cookies sold. As seen on ABC, CBS and NBC.
Christmas cookie gift questions
What are the best Christmas cookie gifts to send?
Send giant stuffed cookies over 5.5 oz, made fresh daily and individually wrapped, in gift packs from $28 or a build-your-own box. Choose flavors they love, from chocolate chip with salted caramel to cake batter with a cake pop core.
What is the last day to order Fat & Weird cookies for Christmas?
December 18 is the Christmas cutoff. Use the paid 2-day shipping option shown above when placing your order.
Is shipping free on Christmas cookie orders?
Orders $55 and up ship free with standard shipping. The 2-day shipping option costs extra.
Will the cookies still be fresh when they arrive?
Made fresh daily, each cookie is individually wrapped and heat-sealed. Cookies are best within 2 weeks of delivery.
Can I send Christmas cookies straight to someone with a note?
Every box includes a free printed gift note, and packing slips never show prices. Follow the steps above to send your gift straight to their door.
Do the cookies need to be baked?
Your cookies arrive ready to eat. To warm one, remove the wrapper and heat it in the oven at 375F for 4 to 6 minutes, the air fryer at 350F for 3 to 6 minutes, or the microwave for 10 to 20 seconds.
Where can I order holiday cookie gifts in bulk for a company?
Order bulk holiday cookie gifts from Fat & Weird Cookie Company through the corporate gifting page. One order can ship to many addresses from a spreadsheet, with tracking for each address available on request.
Do Fat & Weird cookies contain nuts?
Some flavors contain peanuts or tree nuts. We do our best, but our kitchen handles nuts, so cross-contact is a possible risk. Check the allergens on each flavor.
