Top 10 Fan-Favorite Fat & Weird Cookies Ranked

Fat & Weird Cookie isn’t just another cookie company—it’s a movement. With oversized, stuffed, gooey cookies that break all the rules, fans have turned them into viral legends. But which flavors truly stand out? Based on customer favorites and reviews, here’s the official ranking of the Top 10 Fat & Weird Cookies.

1. Chip N’ Drip (The OG Chocolate Chip Stuffed Cookie)

A chocolate chip cookie… but taken to the extreme. Gooey caramel filling, melty chocolate chunks, and a golden brown dough that never misses.

Why fans love it: The ultimate comfort cookie, elevated with a molten center.

2. Party Animal®

A nostalgic confetti sugar cookie bursting with almond flavor and rainbow sprinkles. It’s like a birthday party in every bite.

Why fans love it: Childhood memories + adult-sized indulgence.

3. The Pudge

Peanut butter lovers unite. A rich peanut butter dough stuffed with peanut butter cups and layered with gooey peanut butter filling.

Why fans love it: Triple peanut butter = no regrets.

4. Some More (S’mores)

A campfire classic turned into a mega cookie—graham cookie base, stuffed with marshmallow, layered with milk chocolate, and sprinkled with graham crumbs.

Why fans love it: Mess-free s’mores with all the gooey payoff.

5. Cookies Anonymous

The “Blue Monster” cookie stuffed with Biscoff butter, chocolate sandwich cookie chunks, and white chocolate chips.

Why fans love it: A mashup of fan-favorite cookies in one giant bite.

6. Chocolate Wasted

Decadent chocolate dough stuffed with fudge, loaded with chocolate chips, and finished with a molten chocolate core.

Why fans love it: When one kind of chocolate just isn’t enough.

7. Caked Up

A birthday cake-inspired cookie with cake batter base, white chocolate chunks, and rainbow sprinkles throughout.

Why fans love it: The perfect celebration cookie, anytime.

8. Massive Eruption

Inspired by molten lava cake—this cookie oozes with rich chocolate lava filling and fudgy layers.

Why fans love it: Dramatic, gooey, and Instagram-worthy.

9. Holy Chip

An amped-up chocolate chip cookie with caramel and chocolate pieces throughout, baked to chewy perfection.

Why fans love it: A classic, perfected.

10. Black Beauty

A dark chocolate cookie stuffed with brownie bites and semi-sweet chocolate, delivering deep cocoa richness.

Why fans love it: Bold and intense flavor for serious chocolate lovers.

How to Get the Favorites Pack

The Favorites Pack lets you try all of these legendary cookies in one curated bundle. Each cookie is oversized (5.5oz), stuffed with gooey centers, and individually sealed for freshness.

Order now via: