Skip to content
April’s Best Cookie Recipes – Easy, Fun, and Full of Flavor

April’s Best Cookie Recipes – Easy, Fun, and Full of Flavor


April’s Cookie Recap – What Everyone Was Baking

Fat & Weird Cookie dropped five big cookie stories last month. Some were rich, some went viral, and one was spicy and strange (in a good way). Here’s a quick guide to all of them.

$5 vs. $50 Cookie – Worth the Price?

  • $5 Cookie: Uses Crisco, regular sugar, and basic chocolate chips. Easy and cheap.

  • $50 Cookie: Made with fancy ghee, quail eggs, and expensive Valrhona chocolate. Rich, chewy, and packed with flavor.

Our Take: The $5 cookie is great for every day. The $50 cookie is special – perfect for impressing someone.




Mama Jean vs. Martha Stewart Fired Me – Cookie Battle

  • Mama Jean’s Cookie: A classic family recipe with browned butter and semi-sweet chips. Soft and chewy.

  • Martha Stewart Fired Me Cookie: A viral recipe using three sugars, lots of chocolate, and flaky salt.

Winner: Mama Jean’s cookie. It’s simple, rich, and tastes like home.


Gochujang Caramel Cookie – Sweet + Spicy Combo

This one’s different. It mixes buttery cookie dough with spicy Korean gochujang and caramel.

  • Soft and chewy

  • A little spicy, a little sweet

  • Topped with flake salt

Try it if: You like bold flavors or want something fun and new.


What’s Hot in Cookies Right Now?

  • Fancy baking: Ghee, quail eggs, and flake salt are in.

  • Sweet with spice: The gochujang cookie got people talking.

  • Old-school recipes: Mama Jean’s cookie shows classic still works.



Which Cookie Should You Bake First?

Cookie Best For Flavor Style
$5 Cookie Quick and easy Classic & basic
$50 Cookie Impressing someone Rich & fancy
Mama Jean Comfort baking Buttery & nostalgic
Martha Fired Me Trendy treat Sweet & salty
Gochujang Caramel Bold choice Sweet & spicy



Let’s Bake Together!

Want more fun cookie ideas? Subscribe to the blog for new recipes, tips, and taste tests. Have a weird cookie combo in mind? Leave a comment and we might try it!