Skip to product information
1 of 2

Baker's Choice Cookie

Baker's Choice Cookie

Regular price $4.50 USD
Regular price $5.50 USD Sale price $4.50 USD
Sale Sold out
Shipping calculated at checkout.

All sales are final. We do not offer refunds or cancellations. Stock is extremely limited.

Baker's Choice Cookies are random, with no substitutions or special requests. We do our best to try and give a variety of cookies, but sometimes that is not possible. There is a potential to get multiple of the same cookie. There are no refunds or exchanges.


All F&W cookies are made with the highest quality ingredients. Whether you go for one cookie, six, or a full dozen, these cookies are perfect for any celebration, gift, indulgent night in, or Netflix and chill session. All of our cookies are made fresh to order, with a little crunch on the outside, and a soft gooey center. You can either consume immediately upon receiving your cookie package, warm them up in the microwave if you're into that sort of thing or freeze for a later date. Cookies weigh between 4.5-6 oz.

Cookies processed in a facility/may contain:

  • Dairy, Eggs, Tree Nuts, Peanuts, Wheat, Soy
    View full details
    • Free Shipping

      Free shipping on orders over $75 with code FREESHIP at checkout.

    Rated 4.7 stars
    Based on 3 reviews
    Total 5 star reviews: 2 Total 4 star reviews: 1 Total 3 star reviews: 0 Total 2 star reviews: 0 Total 1 star reviews: 0
    100%would recommend this product
    3 reviews
    • MZ
      Maryssa Z.
      Verified Buyer
      I recommend this product
      Rated 5 stars
      10 seconds ago
      I love these.

      It was delicious! I loved getting surprised with an extra of my favorite cookie or one I haven't tried yet! 😊

    • BF
      Brianna F.
      Verified Buyer
      I recommend this product
      Rated 4 stars
      1 month ago

      I got the incognito cookie and while it wasn’t bad it wasn’t my favorite but I am also not a monster cookie fan. Still would try the bakers choice again to try cookies that I otherwise may not try.

    • KG
      Kayla G.
      Verified Buyer
      I recommend this product
      Rated 5 stars
      1 month ago
      Perfect Choice!!

      My Baker's Choice cookie was The Pudge! I had not tried this one yet, so I was thrilled that I got to try a new cookie. I thought it tasted great with, especially because of the Reese's cup inside! I'm not sure if Fat & Weird Cookies purposefully chooses a cookie for Baker's Choice that the customer hasn't tried yet, but if they do that is a great idea.

    Reviews LoadedReviews Added