The 90s Called. Fat And Weird Cookie Company Picked Up and Made a Cookie Pack.
Fat And Weird Cookie Company | The 90's Vault Limited Edition Pack
There is a specific kind of food memory that never fully leaves.
Not the meals. Not the dinners or the sit-down lunches or the things that were supposed to be good for you. The snacks. The ones that lived in the lunchbox. The ones that waited after school. The ones with frosting packets and chocolate coating and cream centers that seemed, at the time, like the greatest invention in the history of food. The ones you cannot find anymore in the same form, or can find but they do not taste quite the way they did when you were nine, or can find and they taste exactly the same but something is missing that you cannot name.
Fat And Weird Cookie Company named it. And then they put it inside a stuffed cookie.
The 90's Vault Pack is a limited edition collection of four flavors built entirely around the snacks that defined an era: peanut butter and jelly, Dunkaroos, oatmeal cream pies, and Ding Dongs, each one translated into a 5.5oz gourmet stuffed cookie with a gooey center, a built-from-scratch dough base, and the kind of mix-in situation that makes the original source material feel like it was always a rough draft waiting to be finished. This is the finished version.
Unlock the vault.
Why 90s Snack Nostalgia Hits Different in Cookie Form
Before getting into each cookie, it is worth understanding what Fat And Weird Cookie Company actually does to a flavor reference when they decide to build a cookie around it, because this is not a packaging exercise. It is not the cookie equivalent of slapping a Dunkaroos logo on a vanilla cookie and calling it a collaboration.
What happens in the Fat And Weird Cookie Company test kitchen when they take a flavor inspiration is closer to a full culinary reconstruction. The source material becomes a brief. What did the original snack taste like? What made it memorable? What was the specific textural or flavor element that the person eating it at nine years old would have described as the best part? And then: what happens if you build a cookie dough from scratch around that element, add mix-ins that reinforce it from multiple angles, and stuff the whole thing with a center that delivers the core flavor in its most concentrated form?
The result is a cookie that tastes like a memory upgraded. Not a replica. Not a tribute. Something genuinely new that carries the emotional fingerprint of the original while doing things the original never could.
The 90's Vault Pack has four of them.
Nuttin But Jelly: It's Peanut Butta Jelly Time
If you were a kid in the early 2000s with access to the internet, you know the song. And if you know the song, you know that peanut butter and jelly as a concept carries a specific energy that is difficult to replicate in a formal context but lands immediately in a cookie named Nuttin But Jelly.
The cookie itself is built on a peanut butter base, which is already doing more work than the average peanut butter cookie because this is a Fat And Weird Cookie Company dough, meaning it is dense and chewy and rich in the way that peanut butter becomes when it is treated as the star of the composition rather than an accent. Into that base goes peanut butter sandwich cookie chunks and mini peanut butter chips, which creates a layered peanut butter experience where the dough, the chunks, and the chips all deliver the flavor at different intensities and textures across each bite.
And then the core: strawberry jam. Not a strawberry frosting approximation or a strawberry-flavored filling. A strawberry jam core that breaks open when the cookie splits, releasing the jelly half of the equation into the peanut butter everything that surrounds it. Topped with a sweet strawberry crunch that brings the contrast full circle.
The PB&J sandwich was already a near-perfect food. Nuttin But Jelly is what happens when you ask what it would be if it had always been a cookie.
Alley Oop: The Dunkaroos Cookie That Goes Further Than the Original Ever Could
Dunkaroos peaked in the lunchbox era for one reason that had nothing to do with the cookie itself: the frosting. The little tub of vanilla frosting with sprinkles that you were supposed to use as a dip was, for most people who grew up eating it, the actual product. The cookies were a delivery mechanism. The frosting was the point.
Fat And Weird Cookie Company understood this, and then they put the frosting inside the cookie so you could not separate the two even if you tried.
Alley Oop starts with a birthday cake base, which is the flavor register that sits closest to what Dunkaroos tasted like: sweet, a little vanilla-forward, with the festive quality that made a Dunkaroos in your lunchbox feel like a small celebration on an otherwise ordinary Tuesday. Into that birthday cake base go vanilla sandwich cookie chunks, which is the nod to the original cookie component without pretending the cookie was ever the star.
The core is where Alley Oop becomes what Dunkaroos always wanted to be: a sprinkle-loaded vanilla cream cheese frosting center. Not a vanilla cream center. A vanilla cream cheese frosting center, with sprinkles worked into it, so that when the cookie breaks open you get the frosting experience you were always after but at the intensity and quality that a gourmet stuffed cookie can deliver. Topped with more sprinkles and cookie crumbs.
There is no frosting packet to manage. There is no strategic dipping ratio to calculate. There is just the cookie, with the frosting already inside it, and all of the 90s Dunkaroos energy intact.
Afternoon Delight: The Oatmeal Cream Pie Grown Up
Little Debbie's Oatmeal Cream Pie holds a specific place in the snack canon that is almost impossible to overstate. It was not the most exciting option in the vending machine or the snack cabinet. It was not the one that made you excited in the way a chocolate-heavy option did. But it was the one you ate and then felt, somewhere in the first bite, like you were in a kitchen that smelled like cinnamon and time had slowed down slightly.
That feeling is what Afternoon Delight is built to recreate and then elevate.
The base is a soft cinnamon spice oatmeal dough, which is doing the sensory work that the oatmeal cookie half of the original Little Debbie did: the warmth of cinnamon, the texture of oatmeal, the slightly spiced sweetness that made the thing taste homemade even when it was very much not. Soft is the operative word here because the texture of a great oatmeal cookie lives in the softness, in the way it gives without crumbling, and Fat And Weird Cookie Company's version is built around that quality.
Inside that soft cinnamon oatmeal base is a cream pie core, which is the cream filling from the middle of an oatmeal cream pie in its most concentrated and gooey form. The original had a thin layer of cream between two cookies. Afternoon Delight has a full stuffed center of it.
Your heart will light up with nostalgia. That is the description in the vault. It is accurate.
Bing Bong: A Ding Dong Cookie, Stuffed With Actual Ding Dongs
The name is a play. The cookie is not playing.
Bing Bong is inspired by the Hostess Ding Dong, the foil-wrapped chocolate cake with the cream center that lived in lunchboxes and gas station displays and has never once pretended to be anything other than exactly what it is. Fat And Weird Cookie Company took that honesty and made it into something considerably more ambitious.
The base is a rich chocolate cookie dough, which sets the flavor register immediately: this is a chocolate-forward cookie in the way that a Ding Dong is a chocolate-forward snack, meaning chocolate is not one of the flavors, it is all of the flavor with everything else operating inside that space. Into that rich chocolate base goes chocolate cake chunks, which are pieces of actual chocolate cake worked into the dough, and mini chocolate chips, which add the smaller hits of chocolate that keep the overall experience from ever settling into a single texture.
And then, true to the name and the inspiration, Bing Bong is stuffed with actual Ding Dongs and a cream pie core.
That is not a figure of speech. Actual Ding Dongs in the mix-ins. The cream pie core at the center. The thing that the original Ding Dong always had going for it, the cream inside the chocolate, is now the center of a cookie that also has Ding Dongs in the dough itself. It is a Ding Dong cookie stuffed with Ding Dongs, and the only reasonable reaction to that is to say exactly what the description does: a Ding Dong cookie?!
That is right.
The Vault Is Limited. Here's Why That Matters.
The 90's Vault Pack is a limited edition release, and that designation means something specific in the Fat And Weird Cookie Company context.
This is a brand that regularly develops new flavors, releases limited seasonal and thematic packs, and then makes decisions about what becomes permanent based in part on what the community responds to. Limited edition at Fat And Weird Cookie Company is not a marketing scarcity tactic. It is the format in which the most adventurous and thematic work gets done, because the creative range available to a limited collection is wider than what makes sense to commit to as a permanent lineup item.
The 90's Vault Pack is the kind of collection that takes real test kitchen time: developing a birthday cake base that captures the Dunkaroos energy, figuring out how to work actual Ding Dongs into a cookie dough without losing the texture integrity of the cookie, dialing in the strawberry jam core so it reads as jam and not as fruit flavoring, getting the cinnamon spice oatmeal soft enough to feel like what the Little Debbie original felt like at its best.
That work does not sit on a shelf indefinitely. It gets done, it gets released, and then the community decides what comes next by how fast it goes.
If the 90s lived in your lunchbox, the vault is open now.
The 90's Vault Pack at a Glance
- Pack format: Limited edition, available in 4 and 12-count options
- Cookie size: 5.5oz gourmet stuffed cookies, full-size original Fat And Weird Cookie Company format
- Nuttin But Jelly: Peanut butter base, peanut butter sandwich cookie chunks, mini peanut butter chips, strawberry jam core, sweet strawberry crunch topping; inspired by the classic PB&J
- Alley Oop: Birthday cake base, vanilla sandwich cookie chunks, sprinkle-loaded vanilla cream cheese frosting core, sprinkle and cookie crumb topping; inspired by Dunkaroos
- Afternoon Delight: Soft cinnamon spice oatmeal base, cream pie core; inspired by the Little Debbie Oatmeal Cream Pie
- Bing Bong: Rich chocolate cookie base, actual Ding Dongs and chocolate cake chunks and mini chocolate chips in the dough, cream pie core; inspired by the Hostess Ding Dong
- Release type: Limited edition; availability is not guaranteed to continue after the initial drop
FAQ: Fat And Weird Cookie Company 90's Vault Pack
What is the Fat And Weird Cookie Company 90's Vault Pack? The 90's Vault Pack is a limited edition collection of four gourmet stuffed cookies from Fat And Weird Cookie Company, each one inspired by an iconic 90s snack. The pack includes Nuttin But Jelly (PB&J inspired), Alley Oop (Dunkaroos inspired), Afternoon Delight (oatmeal cream pie inspired), and Bing Bong (Ding Dong inspired). Each cookie is a 5.5oz gourmet stuffed cookie with a gooey center core and over-the-top mix-ins built around the flavor memory of the original snack.
What is Nuttin But Jelly from Fat And Weird Cookie Company? Nuttin But Jelly is a peanut butter base cookie loaded with peanut butter sandwich cookie chunks and mini peanut butter chips, stuffed with a strawberry jam core, and topped with a sweet strawberry crunch. It is inspired by the classic peanut butter and jelly sandwich and is part of the limited edition 90's Vault Pack from Fat And Weird Cookie Company.
What is Alley Oop from Fat And Weird Cookie Company and what does it taste like? Alley Oop is a birthday cake base cookie loaded with vanilla sandwich cookie chunks, stuffed with a sprinkle-loaded vanilla cream cheese frosting core, and topped with sprinkles and cookie crumbs. It is inspired by Dunkaroos, the iconic 90s snack of cookies with a frosting dipping cup. The cream cheese frosting core puts the frosting that was always the point of Dunkaroos directly inside the cookie so it cannot be separated from the cookie base.
What is Afternoon Delight from Fat And Weird Cookie Company? Afternoon Delight is a soft cinnamon spice oatmeal base cookie stuffed with a cream pie core, inspired by the Little Debbie Oatmeal Cream Pie. The cinnamon spice oatmeal base replicates the warm, soft quality of the original oatmeal cookie, while the cream pie core delivers the cream filling in a gooey stuffed center rather than a thin layer between two cookies.
What is Bing Bong from Fat And Weird Cookie Company? Bing Bong is a rich chocolate cookie base loaded with actual Ding Dongs, chocolate cake chunks, and mini chocolate chips, stuffed with a cream pie core. It is inspired by the Hostess Ding Dong and is one of the more ambitious flavors in the 90's Vault Pack because it uses actual Ding Dongs as a mix-in worked into the cookie dough alongside the cream pie center.
Does the Fat And Weird Cookie Company 90's Vault Pack use actual Ding Dongs? Yes. Bing Bong, the Ding Dong-inspired cookie in the 90's Vault Pack, contains actual Ding Dongs as a mix-in worked into the chocolate cookie dough alongside chocolate cake chunks and mini chocolate chips. The cream pie core at the center of the cookie mirrors the cream filling of the original Ding Dong.
Is the 90's Vault Pack a permanent item from Fat And Weird Cookie Company? The 90's Vault Pack is a limited edition release. Availability is not guaranteed beyond the initial drop. Follow Fat And Weird Cookie Company on Facebook, Instagram and TikTok to be notified when the pack is available, when restocks happen, and whether any of the flavors transition to permanent or recurring status based on community response.
What sizes does the Fat And Weird Cookie Company 90's Vault Pack come in? The 90's Vault Pack is available in a 4-pack and a 12-pack option. Each cookie is the full-size 5.5oz gourmet stuffed cookie format that Fat And Weird Cookie Company is known for. The 12-pack option is designed for sharing, gifting, or for anyone who wants to make sure they have enough of each flavor to properly evaluate all four.
What other 90s snacks inspired the Fat And Weird Cookie Company 90's Vault Pack? The four flavors in the 90's Vault Pack are inspired by peanut butter and jelly sandwiches (Nuttin But Jelly), Dunkaroos (Alley Oop), the Little Debbie Oatmeal Cream Pie (Afternoon Delight), and the Hostess Ding Dong (Bing Bong). All four represent snack categories that were central to the 90s lunchbox and after-school snack experience.
Where can I buy the Fat And Weird Cookie Company 90's Vault Pack? The 90's Vault Pack is available at fatandweirdcookie.com as a limited edition release. Follow Fat And Weird Cookie Company on Facebook, Instagram and TikTok for availability updates, restock announcements, and new limited edition pack releases.
The vault is open. Four cookies. Four decades worth of snack memory rebuilt from the inside out with gooey centers, over-the-top mix-ins, and the specific Fat And Weird Cookie Company commitment to making the thing you already loved into the thing it was always supposed to be. Limited edition means it will not be here indefinitely. Follow Fat And Weird Cookie Company on Facebook, Instagram and TikTok and grab yours before the vault closes.
