2026 Starts Sweet: Meet the 2025 Fan Favorites Pack 🍪✨
New year, same iconic cravings.
As we kick off January 2026, there’s no better way to celebrate the New Year than by bringing back the cookies everyone couldn’t stop talking about. The flavors that dominated orders, sparked nonstop DMs, and earned true fan favorite status are officially back to start the year strong.
Introducing the 2025 FAN FAVORITES Pack, a highlight worthy lineup created to celebrate fresh beginnings, bold indulgence, and the cookies that defined the year we just wrapped up.
If you’re starting 2026 with big goals, cozy vibes, and zero interest in boring desserts, this pack is your New Year treat.
Why the 2025 Fan Favorites Pack Is the Perfect New Year Drop
This January 2026 release isn’t about resolutions. It’s about celebration.
The 2025 FAN FAVORITES Pack was curated from the most loved cookies of the year. These weren’t seasonal experiments or one time hits. These were the cookies people reordered, recommended, and begged to see again.
Each pack includes one third of each fan favorite flavor, giving you a curated tasting experience of the boldest, richest, and most nostalgic cookies to welcome the New Year.
Think indulgent fillings, bakery style finishes, and flavors that feel familiar but elevated.
The Fan Favorite Lineup
Getting Toasted
Elegant, rich, and unapologetically indulgent.
This crème brûlée inspired cookie starts with a luxurious crème brûlée dough base, stuffed with a silky crème brûlée frosting core. Toffee bits add texture and depth, while a crackly burnt sugar crust delivers that signature caramelized bite.
It’s refined dessert energy, perfect for ringing in the New Year with something a little extra.
Grande Sexy
Big cinnamon churro energy to start 2026 strong.
A warm cinnamon dough base is stuffed with a gooey dulce de leche core, then packed with caramel bits, cinnamon chips, and cinnamon cake donut mix ins. Finished with crunchy turbinado sugar, this cookie brings bakery style indulgence with bold, cozy spice.
Sweet, dramatic, and impossible to ignore.
Starboy
A nostalgic classic with a bold upgrade.
Inspired by the beloved Star Crunch, Starboy features a rich chocolate dough base with a caramel fudge core, caramel bits, chocolate chips, and chewy chocolate caramel cookie mix ins. Topped with cocoa cereal for the perfect crunch, this cookie delivers layers of texture and deep chocolate caramel flavor.
A throwback treat to kick off a brand new year.
The Fluffer
Comfort food energy at its finest.
The Fluffer is inspired by classic Fluffernutter sandwiches, featuring a soft peanut butter dough base stuffed with marshmallow fluff. Peanut butter chips and peanut butter sandwich cookies bring extra richness, making every bite gooey, nostalgic, and satisfying.
The kind of cookie that makes January feel a little warmer.
Start 2026 With Fan Approved Flavor
The 2025 FAN FAVORITES Pack is our way of celebrating the New Year with what you loved most. No filler. No guessing. Just bold, indulgent cookies that earned their place through real fan demand.
Whether you’re treating yourself, sharing with friends, or easing into January with something sweet, this pack sets the tone for 2026 the right way.
Bold flavors. Big nostalgia. Fan approved.
That’s how we’re starting the New Year 🍪🔥
